Ethics
Jeanette Kennett
8 points * First semester * Clayton/Caulfield/Peninsula * Prerequisites: A first-year sequence in philosophy
The subject deals with the following areas of philosophical ethics. (i) Meta-ethics: when we judge an action to be right or wrong, are we merely expressing our personal emotions? Or are we using our reason? Are we making a judgment which is capable of being true or false? The first part of this subject will examine these questions. (ii) Normative ethics: normative theories are theories about what is of value, or what acts are right. A major focus of discussion is the opposition between utilitarian theories and non-utilitarian theories. Utilitarian theories judge the rightness or wrongness of actions solely in accordance with their consequences. Can utilitarianism account for special obligations which arise from personal relationships based on love and friendship? Is there a limit to our responsibility to minimise suffering and to maximise happiness? Is there a rational basis for settling disagreements between people who hold conflicting theories about what we ought to do?
Assessment
Written (5000 words): 80% * Examination (1 hour): 20% * Optional replacement of one essay by a 2-hour examination
Prescribed texts
A collection of readings available from the department
Mackie J L Ethics: inventing right and wrong Penguin